Understanding RBI’s Latest Guidelines on Fraud Risk Management for Co-operative Banks

Governance Structure for Fraud Risk Management

Rising Fraud Risks are disrupting financial operations, leading to a huge potential downside for banks and other financial institutions. RBI’s new regulations aim to tackle this and provide a proper governance structure for Fraud Risk Management. Targeted specifically for Co-operative Banks, including Urban Co-operatives Banks (UCBs), State Co-operative Banks (StCBs), and Central Co-operative Banks (CCBs), Master Directions (MD) on Fraud Risk Management in Urban Co-operative Banks (UCBs) / State Co-operative Banks (StCBs) / Central Co-operative Banks (CCBs) facilitate a comprehensive framework for prevention, early detection and reporting of financial crimes.

This Master Direction for Co-operative Banks delineates policy, roles, responsibilities and procedures for Fraud Risk Management. Let’s delve deep and understand the nitty-gritty details of it:

1. Board-Approved Fraud Risk Management Policy

First, the regulation specifies policy frameworks adhering to Fraud Risk Management for Co-operative Banks. This includes the following:

• All Co-operative Banks in the country must have a proper Fraud Risk Management Policy that should be validated by a Board of Directors.
• This policy should encompass specific details on the bank’s approach to handling Fraud Detection, Investigation, Reporting, and Prevention.
• The curated policy should be regularly reviewed and revamped every three years or sooner if necessary.

2. Issuance of Show Cause Notices (SCNs)

Next, the Master Direction addresses the guidelines to be followed once an anomalous activity is detected from an entity that might be potentially fraudulent.

• Prior to declaring someone fraudulent, the bank must issue a Show Cause Notice (SCNs) and allow them to respond to the accusation within 21 days.
• The bank must provide a fair chance for the suspected entity to defend itself before being labelled as fraudulent.
• This aspect of the regulation effectively provides “Due Process,” balancing the law and individual rights.

3. Special Committee for Monitoring Fraud Cases (SCMFC)

Moving on, the regulation also outlines the roles of a specialised committee for Fraud Risk Management.

• All Co-operative Banks must form a specialised committee to monitor and follow up on fraud cases.
• This committee must include three senior personnel, including a CEO and two board of directors with dedicated experience, to monitor fraud cases and follow up on investigations.
• The committee is responsible for overseeing the effectiveness of security measures, reviewing cases, and identifying areas for improvement to enhance protection.

In addition to the above governance structure, the regulation also recommends the following:

• Encourages whistleblower policies to safeguard employees and personnel who report fraud.
• Effective Fraud Management policy implementation for oversight by senior management.
• Aligning overall organisational structure to best monitor risks, prevent frauds, and report incidents.

The Role of Early Warning Systems (EWS) in Fraud Management

Just by following the governance framework, Co-operatives cannot completely stop frauds in their tracks. In order to do so, banks should integrate a technology-first approach that facilitates early warning signs to notify authorities for swift intervention that aids extensively in prevention processes. Based on the significance of the technology-first approach, the RBI’s Master Direction has defined the role of early warning systems for Fraud Management. Here’s a rundown:

• The EWS assists Co-operatives in identifying early signs of fraud. It acts as a warning system that alerts bank authorities of potential risks, which, without proper intervention, can be detrimental.
• To expound on the key features of an EWS, the system will track transactions and spot unusual behaviour that indicates fraud. With its warning indicators like transaction patterns, account behaviour, and other data, banks can further investigate fraud and resolve it before it escalates.
• The EWS framework is mandatory for only large Co-operative Banks, specifically UCBs in Tier 3 & 4 categories and StCBs & CCBs with deposits over 1000 crore.
• The regulation also demands a robust EWS integration with Core Banking Systems (CBS) to validate each transaction in real-time. This requires the integration of intelligent technology-based solutions that provide true real-time transaction monitoring and behavioural analysis which supports banks with seamless risk management and compliance.
• The guidelines insist Co-operatives take swift remediable action once the fraud is alerted by the EWS. It also recommends that applicable Co-operatives strengthen their EWS for regular monitoring purposes.
• Finally, these regulations are to be implemented within six months of the guidelines being issued.

Preventive Measures and Remedial Action

In addition to the guidelines for governance, real-time detection, EWS and Fraud Prevention, the RBI has also set standards for proactive mitigation and remedial measures.

To further the process of investigating suspicious activities, The Master Directions has broadly classified the regulation into three critical areas. Here’s a brief overview:

• Proactive Investigations

When it comes to investigations, RBI doesn’t want any stone unturned. Therefore, the Master Direction has given specific protocols to follow.

1. Co-operatives should act fast when they detect an anomalous transaction. They can go about this in two different ways. First, they can employ internal auditors, that is, people who are part of the bank, to investigate these transactions or hire external investigators to validate if there has been fraudulent activity.
2. If the bank is opting for a third-party service to investigate frauds, then the bank should implement strict terms and conditions to hold them accountable. This is to curb wilful negligence and malpractice that can lead to a causative factor for fraud.

• Staff Accountability

Next, the direction focuses on staff responsibilities when fraud occurs. If fraud happens due to the bank’s oversight, then the employees are to be held responsible. This indicates that key personnel, like senior executives and the CEO, are obligated to take full responsibility for the incident.

The Audit Committee of the Board (ACB) will then initiate an examination of accountability and decide upon the necessary action.

• Penal Measures

Finally, this revised regulatory framework has specified stringent penal measures for violators. If any individual or organisation is found guilty of fraudulent activities, it will be banned for a complete five years. This includes the convicted individual or entity’s inability to engage in transaction operations with any financial institution regulated by the RBI. After five years, the decision to operate with the individual or entity solely remains in the hands of the bank.

By implementing such civil penalties, the RBI aims to deter fraudulent activities, enhance the integrity of financial ecosystems, and protect the interests of bank customers.

Fraud Reporting and Compliance

Detection and prevention of frauds are not the end of the story. To support the fight against frauds and to investigate the roots of malefactors, banks need to report fraud incidents to RBI and Law Enforcement Agencies (LEAs). The regulatory framework has set the following guidelines for reporting fraud incidents:

• As soon as the Co-operative bank detects a fraud, it should report the fraud to RBI and LEAs. This procedure has a strict deadline of 14 days from the date of identifying fraud.
• Additionally, banks are required to be open and clear in their fraud reporting. For audits and compliance checks, RBI validates accurate fraud reporting that reflects actual incidents.
• To help in the reporting process, banks can leverage intelligent fraud prevention solutions that have built-in automated reporting capabilities. This simplifies the reporting endeavour and complies with the latest regulatory requirements.
• Lastly, the Master Direction has also prescribed the consequences for non-compliance. If a Co-operative fails to comply with the core regulations that are mentioned above, banks are to face severe penalties. This includes financial penalties, restrictions, and increased scrutiny. With its far-reaching effects of non-compliance, banks can also be subjected to damaged reputations and loss of trust from regulatory bodies.

BANKiQ – Safeguarding Payments and Simplifying Compliance

As the payments landscape evolves with changing demands from regulations, financial institutions need to adopt robust fraud risk management systems to protect operations, stay compliant, and ensure security.

BANKiQ is a leading Fraud Risk Management solutions provider that facilitates next-gen solutions to combat Fraud Risks and Compliance challenges. Featuring out-of-the-box capabilities such as multi-channel detection, real-time monitoring,  early warning signals through alerts, customer screening, and behavioural analytics, BANKiQ ensures complete fraud risk management to protect your payment operations.

With extensive expertise in providing payment protection and compliance support to financial institutions, BANKiQ offers its PULSE solution, designed specifically for co-operatives and small banks. By providing end-to-end transaction protection, BANKiQ ensures seamless alignment with the revised RBI regulatory framework, enabling institutions to stay compliant while safeguarding their operations.

Final Note

The recent revision of regulations for Fraud Risk Management for Co-operative Banks underscores the robust framework set forth by the RBI. In this Master Direction, RBI emphasises the significance of real-time fraud detection, Early Warning Systems (EWS), technology-based fraud prevention, and fraud reporting to secure financial operations.

BANKiQ is a modern platform providing purpose-built technological solutions that empower financial institutions to navigate the threat landscape securely and effectively. Equipped with advanced cognitive AI-ML capabilities, BANKiQ solutions seamlessly align with the standards recommended in the Master Directions, ensuring comprehensive fraud risk management and compliance support.

To learn more about these solutions, connect with BANKiQ experts now!